The Lorax Is the Reason My Kid Eats Broccoli

Sarah Rose Levy
Sarah Rose Levy · 5 min read

For months, broccoli night at my house went the same way. I’d put a few florets on the plate, my kid would push the plate an inch away, and we’d both sit there like two people waiting for the other one to blink.

I tried everything I could think of: cheese sauce (dairy, so not the vegan route), “just one bite,” the airplane and the dinosaur. There was also a deal involving dessert that I’m not proud of.

Nothing. The broccoli went back in the fridge every single time.

Then one night we read The Lorax at bedtime. The next evening my kid looked down at the plate, went quiet for a second and said, “Those are Truffula Trees.”

And then ate one.

Those really are tiny Truffula Trees, if you squint

Those really are tiny Truffula Trees, if you squint

I could see it: a fluffy tuft on a stalk, just shorter and greener on the plate. The book never mentions broccoli. That connection was all my kid’s.

My kid wasn’t being dramatic. Broccoli actually tastes worse to some kids

My kid wasn't being dramatic. Broccoli actually tastes worse to some kids

Once broccoli started disappearing, I got curious about why the refusal had been so total in the first place. The answer kind of embarrassed me.

In one 2006 study of 65 preschoolers, kids who tasted a bitter test compound called PROP liked raw broccoli less and ate fewer vegetables than kids who didn’t taste it. That was one test session, but it made me rethink the standoff.

A gene called TAS2R38 shapes how bitter some of these compounds taste to a person. I have no idea which way my kid’s genes went, because nobody tested anybody.

Then it got weirder. A 2021 study from Australia’s CSIRO looked at 98 parent and child pairs, with kids aged 6 to 8.

They mixed each person’s saliva with raw cauliflower powder and measured the sulfur smells released by enzymes from the vegetable and mouth bacteria. I’d been arguing about a floret without even considering what happened once it reached a mouth.

The kids whose saliva made the most of those sulfur smells disliked raw brassicas the most. Adults didn’t show the same link, and an association in a raw-food test couldn’t tell me why my kid refused dinner.

So for some kids, their own spit makes raw broccoli smell worse. That was the moment I stopped calling it stubbornness. My kid might have been tasting a different vegetable than I was.

Turns out a book can do what I couldn’t

Turns out a book can do what I couldn't

Here’s the part that really got me. There’s actual research on picture books and toddlers trying vegetables.

In a 2014 study, parents read a picture book about a fruit or vegetable with their toddler every day for two weeks. In one experiment with 57 toddlers aged 20 to 24 months, the kids ate more of the unfamiliar vegetable from their book than a matched vegetable they hadn’t seen in it. They also needed less coaxing to taste it.

Now, I’m not going to oversell this. Those were toddlers, the vegetables were unfamiliar ones, and the books were simple photo books about the vegetable itself.

Earlier work from the same group even found that familiar vegetables like carrots and sweetcorn were less likely to get tasted after showing up in a book. Broccoli was very familiar in my house. Familiar and hated.

And The Lorax isn’t a photo book about broccoli. It’s a story about a guy who wrecks a forest. That study didn’t test whether Seuss gets kids to eat greens, and I’m not claiming he does.

My guess, and it’s only a guess, is that it’s the same family of thing. The book made those little trees something my kid already knew and cared about. Begging never did that.

It wasn’t one magic night, and I’m not going to pretend it was

It wasn't one magic night, and I'm not going to pretend it was

I’d love to tell you the Truffula line fixed everything in one dinner. It didn’t.

I’d put broccoli on that plate at least a dozen times before the trees showed up, and the first “tree” got about two nibbles before it was declared done. The win was that it went in a mouth at all.

But those earlier servings were offerings, not tastes. In one school study, fourth and fifth graders in Louisiana actually tasted carrots, peas, tomatoes and bell peppers once a week for 10 weeks.

Among kids who started out disliking those vegetables, more of them said they liked them after eight or nine tastes. It worked for carrots, peas and tomatoes, but not bell peppers. And it only clicked for about half the kids.

Broccoli wasn’t even in that study, so don’t let anyone tell you there’s a magic number for broccoli. There isn’t one that I could find.

A 2018 review of studies in children also found that repeated exposure increased liking and intake of the vegetable being tried. The effects were small, and evidence for long-term benefits was limited. I took that as a reason to keep my expectations modest.

At my table, I had a first taste after a lot of refusals. I think the book helped make that bite possible, but I can’t credit the earlier untouched servings with doing the work of repeated tastes.

I also quit boiling the life out of it

I also quit boiling the life out of it

This one’s more for me than for the kid. I used to boil broccoli until a fork went through it with zero resistance.

A 2007 study from the University of Warwick gave me a reason to stop: boiling broccoli for 30 minutes cut its glucosinolates, the compounds broccoli is known for, by 77%. Steaming, microwaving and stir-frying caused no significant loss within the cooking times tested.

So now I steam it or toss it in a hot pan. I can’t tell you that changed how it tastes to my kid, because that’s not what the study measured. I just like it better, and I’m done pouring a big chunk of the good stuff down the drain.

What’s in those little trees anyway

Since my kid now eats a small forest on a good night, I looked up what’s actually in there. A cup of chopped raw broccoli, about 91 grams, has roughly:

  • 31 calories
  • 2.4 grams of fiber
  • 81 mg of vitamin C, which is about 90% of the daily value for an adult

Those are raw numbers from the USDA. Cooking changes them.

I speak for the trees, and then I eat them

These days, broccoli night has a ritual. My kid holds up a floret, announces “I speak for the trees, for the trees have no tongues,” and bites the top clean off.

Eat better, meat-free.

Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.

Sarah Rose Levy
Written by Sarah Rose Levy

Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.

More Like This