I Made Pumpkin Dumplings From Scratch and Here’s What Went Wrong

Sarah Rose Levy
Sarah Rose Levy · 5 min read

My bamboo steamer basket is still orange. It’s not sauce. It’s the bottoms of my pumpkin dumplings, which stayed welded to the bamboo when I finally pried the rest of them up.

That was just how the night ended.

Before that, I turned a spare Halloween carving pumpkin into a filling that was basically soup. I made a cold-water dough that shrank back every time I rolled it, and I pleated wrappers that slowly yawned back open.

I thought folding would be the hard part. I hadn’t even questioned whether my carving pumpkin belonged in the filling or whether cold tap water made sense for dough I planned to steam.

Those choices had me in trouble before I pinched a single pleat.

My first mistake was the pumpkin I already had

My first mistake was the pumpkin I already had

I bought two big carving pumpkins for Halloween and only got around to carving one. The spare sat on the counter looking at me, and the week after, I decided it was going to be dinner.

When I cut it open, the inside was stringy, wet and tasted like almost nothing. I kept scraping out what looked like soggy orange yarn.

I’d treated a carving pumpkin as a bigger pie pumpkin. Iowa State University’s extension service describes field pumpkins as having “watery, stringy flesh,” which was exactly what I was scraping off my spoon.

Mine was edible, but I’d passed over the small pie (or sugar) pumpkins with their denser, smoother, sweeter flesh. Using the spare meant dealing with more water and stringiness, and I’d made no allowance for either.

I did not work harder. I worked about the same.

I basically made pumpkin soup and tried to fold it

I basically made pumpkin soup and tried to fold it

I cooked the pumpkin down, mashed it with ginger, scallions and a splash of soy sauce, and spooned it straight into wrappers. It was closer to a dip than a filling.

Raw pumpkin is about 92% water by weight, according to USDA data. I had essentially tried to gift-wrap a puddle.

Wet filling is the classic dumpling killer. Chef Kenny Leung puts it bluntly: if the filling’s too wet, “the moisture will break up the dumpling!” Mine broke up on the cutting board before it got anywhere near the heat.

The fix is getting the water out before anything goes into a wrapper. Salt it a little, let it sit, then wring it out hard in a clean tea towel or cheesecloth. You’ll be shocked at what comes out.

I also boiled my pumpkin, which I now suspect was the worst possible way to cook something that’s already mostly water. That’s my theory, not science, but next time it’s getting roasted.

Cold water was the wrong call for steamed dumplings

Cold water was the wrong call for steamed dumplings

The dough was the part I was proud of. Flour, cold tap water and a lot of kneading. Then I tried to roll it out and it shrank back like I’d insulted it.

I’d assumed water temperature was a detail I could ignore. For the softer, less stretchy dough I wanted to steam, I’d use boiling water next time: it breaks down gluten and gelatinizes many of the starches.

Instead, my cold water let the gluten develop into the springy, chewy dough better suited to boiled dumplings and noodles. I’d picked dough that could hold up in water, then steamed it into something tough enough to count as a jaw workout.

I wouldn’t need to change the ingredients, just the water temperature. My flour-and-water dough was already vegan.

I also skipped resting it, because I was hungry. Next time I’d give it the covered rest of 30 minutes to an hour that I’d hurried past. I gave mine roughly zero.

Turns out you can’t glue dough with flour

Turns out you can't glue dough with flour

By the time I’d rolled out a stack of wrappers, my kitchen looked like a bakery had exploded. I’d floured everything so the stubborn dough wouldn’t stick, and the wrappers at the bottom of the pile had started drying out.

I’d also overstuffed every single one and smeared orange on most of the edges. So I’d pinch a pleat, let go, and watch it slowly yawn back open.

I’d left the wrappers uncovered while I wrestled with each pleat, giving those edges time to dry out and stop sealing. Next time I’d keep the waiting wrappers under a damp towel or plastic wrap and brush a little water on any dry edges.

The flour I’d scattered everywhere was making the seal harder too. I’d turn the less-floured side up and keep my orange filling off the edges, instead of trying to pinch through a smear that could make the dumpling fall apart.

I’d also put less filling in each one. Mine tore before they ever saw steam.

Then I welded them to the steamer

Then I welded them to the steamer

The few that did seal went straight onto the bare bamboo. By the time they were cooked, they’d basically fused with it.

I kept lifting the lid to check on them, which made everything worse. Every peek lets the steam out and drops the pressure, so they just take longer to cook.

When I finally pried them up, the bottoms stayed behind. That’s the orange basket from the top of this post.

The fix is almost insultingly simple. Line the basket with napa cabbage leaves or a few layers of clean, wet cheesecloth, then leave the lid alone.

I boiled the next batch out of spite. I had the water at a furious rolling boil, and a few of them burst. Keep it at a boil, just not bubbling like a witch’s cauldron, and stay next to the pot, because they cook fast.

The ones I saved for later fused into one giant dumpling

The ones I saved for later fused into one giant dumpling

I had a handful of uncooked ones left, so I tossed them into a freezer bag together, still soft, and felt very organized about it.

A few days later I pulled out a single frozen orange brick.

What I should have done is freeze them raw on a tray, spread out so they aren’t touching, and bag them only once they’re solid. And don’t let them sit out on the counter until they dry out first. That’s a different problem, not a shortcut.

The can in my pantry wasn’t the pumpkin I pictured either

The can in my pantry wasn't the pumpkin I pictured either

That evening, faced with my runny filling, I noticed a can of pumpkin in the pantry and seriously considered quitting.

I’d pictured the can holding a smoother version of my carving pumpkin. Most U.S. canned pumpkin is made from Dickinson, a tan, oblong Cucurbita moschata variety closer to butternut squash than to a jack-o’-lantern.

“Pumpkin” isn’t a strict botanical category, so the label wasn’t the problem. My assumption that anything called pumpkin would behave like the filling I pictured was.

Next Year I’m Buying the Boring Little Pumpkin

Two carving pumpkins went into this. The best thing either of them ever became was the one with a face.

Next October, the spare is a small, dull-looking pie pumpkin. The big ones can stick to what they’re actually good at, which is grinning at people from a safe distance.

Eat better, meat-free.

Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.

Sarah Rose Levy
Written by Sarah Rose Levy

Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.

More Like This