10 Pumpkin Varieties Ranked for Eating, From Silky to Stringy

Sarah Rose Levy
Sarah Rose Levy · 7 min read

The pumpkin in your can was grown for eating. The one you carve was bred for size, color and a stem you can carry it by.

Choose for flavor and texture and you can get a sweeter pumpkin or a silkier pie.

This post ranking draws on published pie tests, extension guidance and variety descriptions, with storage and availability as secondary considerations.

These 10 varieties haven’t all faced off in one controlled test, so the order weighs those trade-offs rather than following a single texture scale.

Here’s how they stack up for eating.

1. Winter Luxury

1. Winter Luxury

“Whoa. The texture is luxury. Silky.”

That’s what one of Sunset’s tasters wrote about Winter Luxury, which scored 4.7 out of 5 and won the test kitchen’s pie showdown outright. Other tasters called it the “most well balanced” and said they liked its “nuanced flavor.”

Every pie in the test used the same recipe, a crème fraîche pie with a gingersnap layer, with only the squash swapped out. So the winning slice had dairy in it.

Winter Luxury is an heirloom that Johnson & Stokes of Philadelphia introduced in 1893. You can spot it by the fine white netting over its golden skin, like it showed up wearing a lace doily.

It’s small, around 6 pounds. The trade-off is that it doesn’t store as well as other winter squash, so this is one to cook soon, not one to keep on the counter until spring.

2. Kabocha

2. Kabocha

A freshly picked kabocha tastes dry and bland. Give it time and it turns into one of the sweetest pumpkins you can buy.

It’s typically ripened somewhere warm for about 13 days to turn some of its starch into sugar, then held somewhere cool for around a month. What comes out the other end is smooth and sweet, often described as sweeter than butternut, with a taste and texture somewhere between a pumpkin and a sweet potato.

That means the one at the farm stand that came off the vine yesterday may be the blandest kabocha there.

In Sunset’s test, kabocha came second with a 3.5. Tasters called it “creamy, almost nutty and sweet” and said it seemed to have “the most complex flavor.”

One more wrinkle: not every kabocha-type pumpkin eats the same. Nofima, a Norwegian food research institute, found one Hokkaido variety grouped with the drier, firmer pumpkins suited to stews and roasting, while another landed with the soft, creamy ones suited to pies and soups.

3. Long Island Cheese

3. Long Island Cheese

This one looks like a big waxed wheel of cheese. Flat, tan, wide-ribbed and about a foot across, it usually weighs somewhere between 6 and 12 pounds.

It’s also one of the oldest pumpkins around. Hedrick’s 1937 book The Cucurbits of New York called it “one of the oldest varieties cultivated in America,” and it was introduced commercially in 1807.

The name comes from its old job. It was once the preferred pie pumpkin in New York, New Jersey and on Long Island.

So why isn’t it higher? The seed company Fedco is blunt about it. The flesh is “coarse and quite fibrous,” but, in Fedco’s words, “its sweetness redeems its textural deficiencies.”

Translation: it’s very sweet, it’s not silky, and it keeps for months. If you want a pumpkin that’s still good long after Thanksgiving, this is your pick. Its reported sweetness and old pie-making reputation earn it the edge here over finer-grained Musquée de Provence, with storage adding to its appeal.

4. Musquée de Provence

4. Musquée de Provence

In French markets, this pumpkin is often sold by the wedge instead of whole.

It belongs to the same flat, ribbed “cheese pumpkin” family as Long Island Cheese, and it looks so much like a storybook illustration that it also goes by “Fairytale.”

Seed sellers describe the flesh as deep orange, fine-grained and dense, with a sweet, complex flavor that holds its texture when it’s cooked.

Those are growers’ descriptions, not test scores. Treat this spot as a strong reputation rather than a measured result.

5. Dickinson

5. Dickinson

If you’ve eaten canned pumpkin in the US, you’ve probably eaten Dickinson without ever recognizing it.

It doesn’t look like a jack-o’-lantern at all. It’s a tall, blocky, sandy-tan thing that weighs 10 to 14 pounds and could pass for an oversized butternut squash. That’s no coincidence, because it’s the same species as butternut.

Dickinson is behind most of the canned pumpkin sold in the US. It was first grown in Kentucky in the early 19th century and named for farmer Elijah Dickinson, who took it to central Illinois.

Libby’s grows its own proprietary strain with extra dense, sweet flesh.

The flesh is dry and fine-grained, and it tastes something like a cross between butternut and kabocha.

The FDA allows the label “pumpkin” on products made from golden-fleshed, sweet squash or mixtures of those squash with field pumpkin. That allowance explains why canned “pumpkin” can contain sweet squash.

The canned entry in Sunset’s test came last and was identified as Farmer’s Market brand, so that result isn’t a test of Dickinson itself. Dickinson earns fifth place here for its dense, dry flesh, with the consistency and year-round convenience of the can tipping the balance. That’s an editorial trade-off, not a claim that it beat the fresh varieties below it in a taste test.

6. Seminole

6. Seminole

The Seminole people grew this pumpkin up trees.

According to the University of Florida’s IFAS extension, they planted the vines below trees, which served as natural trellises. Those vines can run over 25 feet, so the pumpkins ended up hanging from the branches.

Seminole pumpkins were traditionally grown by the Calusa, Creek and Miccosukee peoples. They usually weigh 6 to 12 pounds.

UF describes the flesh as orange, similar to butternut but sweeter, and firmer and less fibrous than a jack-o’-lantern’s.

The skin is the other selling point. It’s thick enough that the pumpkin keeps a couple of months even in Florida’s humidity, and up to a year somewhere dry with good airflow.

7. Jarrahdale

7. Jarrahdale

Jarrahdale is the blue-gray pumpkin you’ve seen on a nice porch and assumed was fake.

It’s an heirloom bred in Australia and named for the town of Jarrahdale in Western Australia. The slate-colored skin hides sweet orange flesh that cuts easily.

Sunset’s tasters gave it a 3.1. They found “mild caramel notes” and called it “mellow,” though one said it was “a little too sweet.”

Another said it reminded them of a pie their grandmother made, which is about the highest praise a pie can get.

Katie Kammler, a horticulture specialist with University of Missouri Extension, named Jarrahdale among the varieties she’d rather eat than a carving pumpkin. It’s also a good keeper, so you can decorate with it first and eat it later.

8. Sugar Pie

8. Sugar Pie

This is the pumpkin most grocery stores label “pie pumpkin.” In Sunset’s test, it came fourth out of five, ahead of only the can.

It scored a 2.9. Tasters called it “sweet and clean tasting” and the “least earthy,” but one summed it up as “yummy but not as flavorful as others.”

Fine. Not great.

Sugar Pie runs about 6 to 8 inches across and around 6 pounds, and you’ll also see it sold as New England Pie or Boston Pie.

To be fair, it still beats the can. America’s Test Kitchen tasters preferred a pie made with fresh sugar pumpkin over canned, saying the fresh one had “a pleasant squash flavor” while the canned pie “tasted predominantly of the spices.”

ATK also points out that sugar pumpkins have denser, drier flesh than bigger pumpkins but are “still somewhat watery.” That’s the gap between this one and the top of the list.

9. Rouge Vif d’Étampes (Cinderella)

9. Rouge Vif d'Étampes (Cinderella)

Nobody agrees about this pumpkin, and that’s the most interesting thing about it.

It’s a French heirloom from the early 1800s, named for a town south of Paris, and Burpee brought it to the US in 1883. It’s deeply ridged, burnt orange to red, and anywhere from 7 to 30 pounds. It’s widely said to have inspired the name “Cinderella,” for obvious reasons.

The critics are harsh. One authority quoted by Fedco says it “coasts on its looks alone” and calls it “insipid and watery.”

Then Nofima’s sensory panel grouped it with the drier, firmer pumpkins suited to stews and roasting. That’s close to the opposite of watery.

So which is it? The honest answer is that the reviews are split. Even a Vermont grower who defends it and keeps cooking with it admits the flavor is milder and the texture fibrous.

It also has thin skin and doesn’t store well. It’s gorgeous, but you’re taking a gamble.

10. Howden

10. Howden

Howden is the classic jack-o’-lantern, and it was never meant to be dinner.

John Howden of Massachusetts developed it for carving decades ago. Kammler says it’s the most common decorative variety and was “bred for size, shape, color and having a handle-like stem for easy carrying.”

Her verdict on eating carving pumpkins: “If it was my choice, [carving pumpkins] are not what I’d want to eat.”

It’s safe to eat. The flesh is just stringier and more watery than smaller, sweeter pumpkins.

One real warning, though. An FDA spokesperson noted that carved pumpkins may have sat outside for days, exposed to dirt, insects and possibly wax and smoke.

Don’t eat that one. The FDA’s suggestion was to save the seeds and roast them soon after carving.

Your Pie Doesn’t Need a Handle

At the pumpkin stand, ask what the variety tastes like. You’re buying the filling, not a carrying case.

Eat better, meat-free.

Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.

Sarah Rose Levy
Written by Sarah Rose Levy

Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.

More Like This