Is It Vegetarian
For years I was the Thanksgiving guest who quizzed every host about the stuffing and the gravy.
Then I’d go back for seconds of the one dish held together with collagen from animal skin and bones.
It was the sweet potato casserole. More exactly, the puffy marshmallows on top.
The ingredients on that bag read like a candy bar: corn syrup, sugar, dextrose, modified cornstarch, water. Then, tucked near the end, “contains less than 2% of gelatin.”
That one word changed what I put on my casserole. Now I know what to look for on the bag, and I can keep the sweet potatoes and the fluffy topping without the animal gelatin.

The sweet potato casserole never got a single question. It was sweet potatoes, brown sugar and butter (dairy), with a puffy golden lid of marshmallows on top.
It was orange. It looked like a craft project. What could possibly be hiding in there?
That was my blind spot. Somewhere along the way I’d decided the risky food was anything brown and savory, and anything that tasted like dessert got waved through.

Less than 2% sounded like nothing until I looked up what gelatin actually is. It’s partially broken-down collagen taken from animal body parts. Most of it comes from pork skins, pork and cattle bones, or split cattle hides.
So the fluffy white layer on my “vegetable” side was held together with collagen from skin and bones. I’d been eating it with a straight face for years.
What really got me is that the bag just said “gelatin.” It didn’t name an animal. If you don’t already know what gelatin is, nothing on that label is going to tell you.
A modern marshmallow is basically sugar, water and air, plus a whipping agent that’s usually a protein. In most supermarket marshmallows, that protein is gelatin. The gelatin-free ones exist, but they weren’t the ones landing in my cart.

Here’s the part that made me laugh out loud. The original marshmallow was made from a plant.
The old French candy, pâte de guimauve, was a spongy-soft treat made by whipping dried marshmallow root with sugar, water and egg whites (eggs, if you’re vegan). Yes, there’s a plant called marshmallow, and its root was the whole point.
Eventually, candy makers swapped the mallow root out for gelatin, because gelatin made a more stable marshmallow. That’s the version that ended up on grocery store shelves and, eventually, on top of my sweet potatoes.
So a gelatin-free marshmallow isn’t some newfangled substitute. In one way, it’s closer to the original than the bag I’d been buying for years.

I’d defended this dish at the table as “tradition” more than once. Then I found its earliest known printed marshmallow-topped recipe in a company’s marketing booklet.
In 1917, the Angelus Marshmallow company hired Janet McKenzie Hill, founder of The Boston Cooking-School Magazine, to write recipes for a booklet. The goal was to get people using marshmallows as an everyday ingredient, not just a candy you eat out of the bag.
That booklet holds the earliest known printed recipe for mashed sweet potatoes baked under a marshmallow topping. That tells me someone was promoting it, not who first made it.
Sweet potato puddings were around long before that booklet, so I can’t give a marshmallow company credit for the whole dish.
I still get to call it tradition. I just have to admit that the earliest printed version we know of was also selling marshmallows.

After the gelatin reveal, my first fix was buying a bag with a kosher symbol on it. My logic was simple. Kosher means no pork, so no pork gelatin, so I’m in the clear.
Not even close. The Vegetarian Resource Group went looking at a natural foods trade show and found kosher-labeled marshmallows made with beef gelatin.
I’d mistaken kosher for vegetarian. The beef gelatin was enough to show me why a kosher symbol alone couldn’t answer my question.
Now I look for “gelatin-free” or “vegan” printed right on the bag. If it says kosher and still lists gelatin, I’d want to know where that gelatin came from before it goes on anything I’m eating.

Once I’d caught one, I started reading everything.
For years I’d asked whether the stuffing was cooked inside the bird. I never once asked whether it came out of a box that had chicken in it before it got anywhere near the turkey.
The chicken-flavored boxed stuffing mix lists dried cooked chicken and dried chicken broth, right there next to the wheat flour, onion, celery and parsley. I’d always read “chicken” on the front as a flavor description. It’s an ingredient.
That’s the chicken-flavored kind. I haven’t checked every flavor on the shelf, so I’m not going to tell you they’re all like that. I’m telling you I read the side of the box now, every time.
Gelatin-free marshmallows exist, and the ones I’ve found are usually made with carrageenan, which comes from seaweed. They often use tapioca starch and soy protein too.
Agar and pectin are two more non-animal gelling agents, and some marshmallows use agar instead of gelatin. If the bag says gelatin-free or vegan, that’s my green light.
Some years I skip the marshmallows entirely. The older sweet potato dishes got along fine without them, and that 1840 pudding wore a whipped egg-white topping (contains eggs).
My other go-to is a pecan and brown sugar crumble. It browns, it crunches, and nobody at my table has asked where the marshmallows went.
You don’t need a new recipe for any of this. Mash the sweet potatoes the way you always do. Just change what goes on top.
I can’t say a marshmallow company invented my Thanksgiving tradition. I can say its earliest known printed marshmallow-topped recipe came with a sales pitch.
Honestly, I should have seen it coming. It was the only side on the table with its own marketing department.
Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.
Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.
Is It Vegetarian

Is It Vegetarian

Is It Vegetarian