20 Foods That Pair Perfectly With Pumpkin
Starbucks’ Pumpkin Spice Latte went more than a decade without any actual pumpkin in it.
You can also pair pumpkin with crushed cookies in Italian pasta, mustard-spiked apple preserves or coconut custard steamed inside the squash itself.
Here are 20 foods that pair perfectly with pumpkin, plus the stories behind why each one works.
1. Cinnamon

The “pumpkin spice” everyone argues about each fall is a product McCormick started selling in 1934.
The blend is cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and allspice, and cinnamon is the one you smell first.
According to McCormick, by 2019 it was the fourth best-selling retail spice from September through November, and fall brings in about 80% of its yearly retail sales.
McCormick didn’t invent the idea, though. American cooks were already spicing pumpkin more than a century earlier (see number 4).
Cinnamon works because it smells sweet without adding sugar, so pumpkin tastes like dessert with less of it.
A pinch in pumpkin soup or chili adds warmth, not sweetness.
2. Coffee

Starbucks introduced the Pumpkin Spice Latte in 2003.
For more than a decade, the “pumpkin” in the name was all spice and no squash.
Then in August 2015, Starbucks changed the recipe to include actual pumpkin and dropped the artificial colors.
The best part is the quote.
Product manager Peter Dukes reportedly told The Atlantic in 2013 that the drink would never contain pumpkin: “If we changed the recipe now, we’d have a revolt.”
Two years later, in went the pumpkin.
The pairing itself works because coffee’s bitterness cuts through sweet, spiced pumpkin.
Heads up for vegans: the 2015 sauce listed condensed skim milk.
3. Beans

Beans and pumpkin don’t just share a pot. They share a field.
In the Three Sisters planting, corn gives beans something to climb.
Beans pull nitrogen out of the air and turn it into fertilizer for the soil.
The big leaves of squash and pumpkin vines cover the ground like living mulch, which holds in water and keeps weeds down.
The USDA’s National Agricultural Library says archaeological evidence shows this trio had become the dominant food-plant team in the farming northeast of what’s now the US by around AD 1070.
So when you throw beans and pumpkin into the same chili or stew, you’re cooking them the way they’ve always grown.
4. Ginger

The first cookbook by an American author already had ginger in its pumpkin.
Amelia Simmons published American Cookery in 1796, and it includes two “pompkin” puddings.
The first is baked in a crust with stewed pumpkin, plenty of cream and eggs, sugar, mace, nutmeg and ginger.
The second goes with milk, eggs, molasses, allspice and, again, ginger.
Both versions include dairy and eggs. They put ginger next to pumpkin in print by 1796.
It’s the bite that keeps a sweet pumpkin dish from going flat.
Fresh ginger works too. Grate a little into pumpkin soup or a stir-fry for a brighter, sharper heat.
5. Maple Syrup

It takes about 40 gallons of maple sap to make one gallon of syrup.
Maple and pumpkin are both native North American foods, and maple works in both directions.
It sweetens a pie, and it glazes roasted pumpkin for dinner.
Maple syrup is graded by color and flavor. Darker syrups taste stronger, which suits roasted pumpkin and baking.
For a glaze, toss pumpkin cubes with maple, olive oil and salt, then roast at 400°F until caramelized.
Add the maple near the end if you’re roasting longer. Sugar burns faster than the pumpkin cooks.
It’s vegan, too, which makes it the easy stand-in for honey in any pumpkin recipe.
6. Corn

In the Three Sisters, corn is the ladder. It’s the stalk the beans climb while pumpkin spreads out underneath.
Pumpkin’s family showed up first, though.
A 1997 study in Science dated domesticated squash seeds from Guilá Naquitz Cave in Oaxaca to about 10,000 years ago, which makes squash one of the first domesticated plants in the Americas.
So squash was being farmed in Mexico long before anyone grew it next to corn and beans.
For your plate, try cornbread, polenta or sweet corn alongside roasted pumpkin.
Corn’s sweetness matches pumpkin’s, so add something sharp, like chile, lime or cheese, to keep it from tasting flat.
7. Allspice

Allspice isn’t a blend. It’s one dried berry.
It comes from Pimenta dioica, a tree in the myrtle family native to Jamaica and Central America.
It got its name because it tastes like cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves rolled together.
One berry doing the work of a whole spice rack.
No wonder it made both McCormick’s pumpkin pie spice and Simmons’s second 1796 pudding.
A little goes a long way, so start with a pinch and taste.
Whole berries keep their flavor longer than ground. Grind them yourself for the strongest taste.
In Jamaica, it’s the backbone of jerk seasoning, and it works on roasted pumpkin the same way.
8. Chiles

Pumpkin’s relatives and chiles were domesticated in overlapping parts of Mexico.
A 2014 study in PNAS traced domesticated chili peppers to central-east Mexico, a stretch running from southern Puebla and northern Oaxaca to southeastern Veracruz, thousands of years ago.
Squash’s earliest domestication evidence also comes from Oaxaca.
Pipián is a sauce built on ground pepitas (pumpkin seeds) and chiles, and it’s described as having pre-Hispanic roots.
The green version, pipián verde, adds green chiles, tomatillos and greens, and it’s tied to Puebla.
Restaurants often pour pipián over meat.
Spoon it over roasted squash or vegetables instead, and pumpkin ends up both in the sauce and under it.
9. Honey (and Milk)

The first American pumpkin “pies” reportedly weren’t pies at all.
One early New England method, as the story goes, was to hollow out a pumpkin, fill it with milk, spices and honey, and cook the whole thing in the hot ashes of a fire.
There was no crust, and settlers often had no oven anyway.
It’s folk history rather than a surviving recipe, but the pairing holds up.
Honey and milk aren’t vegan, and maple syrup (number 5) is the obvious swap for the honey.
Today you can borrow the idea. Bake a small pumpkin whole with a spiced custard filling inside.
10. Apples

In Mantua, Italy, apples go into a fruit preserve with a kick you can feel in your sinuses.
Mostarda mantovana is often made from mele campanine, small, hard, sour heritage apples grown mainly around Mantua and Cremona.
It’s spiked with a few drops of mustard essence, which Italians buy at the pharmacy.
Quince is the other traditional fruit.
Sweet, sour and hot all at once.
That apple mostarda is a standard ingredient in Mantua’s most famous pumpkin dish, which brings us to the cookies.
Closer to home, tart apples balance sweet pumpkin in soup, pie filling or a roasted tray.
11. Amaretti Cookies

In Mantua, people put crushed cookies in their pasta. On purpose.
Tortelli di zucca are pasta parcels stuffed with pumpkin, crushed amaretti, apple mostarda, grated cheese and a pinch of nutmeg.
They’re traced back to the Renaissance court of Mantua and are the traditional first course on Christmas Eve.
Amaretti di Saronno get their bitter-almond taste from apricot kernels, mixed with sugar and egg whites (so they’re not vegan).
That bitterness is the whole point. It keeps sweet pumpkin from tasting like dessert.
One catch: the traditional filling uses Parmigiano or Grana, and both are made with animal rennet (more at number 13).
Use a vegetarian hard cheese, or just steal the amaretti trick and crumble a few over roasted pumpkin.
12. Sage

Mantua’s tortelli don’t get tomato sauce.
They get melted butter infused with sage leaves and a generous shower of grated cheese.
Butter and sage is the classic Italian partner for pumpkin pasta.
Sage brings a savory, slightly bitter edge, and the butter adds the fat pumpkin barely has (number 20 explains why that matters).
Butter is dairy. Olive oil and sage do the same job for vegans.
Crisp the leaves in the butter until they stop sizzling. They turn crunchy and lose their raw, dusty edge.
Fresh sage beats dried here, since dried leaves turn bitter and won’t crisp at all.
13. Parmesan-Style Hard Cheese

Salty, nutty hard cheese is the contrast sweet pumpkin begs for. The catch is the label.
Parmigiano Reggiano is made with only milk, salt and rennet, and its PDO production rules allow only calf rennet.
That makes the real thing off the table for a vegetarian plate. Grana Padano also uses animal rennet.
Plenty of US producers make Parmesan-style cheese with microbial or vegetable rennet instead.
It can’t be called Parmigiano-Reggiano, but it grates the same.
Look for a vegetarian Parmesan-style cheese (check the label for microbial or vegetable rennet). It’s still dairy, of course.
Grate it over roasted pumpkin or pumpkin risotto right before serving.
14. Nutmeg

Nutmeg and mace come from the same fruit.
Nutmeg is the seed of Myristica fragrans, and mace is the red, lacy coating wrapped around it.
Simmons’s 1796 pudding used both.
Mantua’s tortelli filling calls for a pinch of nutmeg, and a pinch is the right word.
In large amounts, far beyond a pinch, nutmeg is toxic.
Freshly grated nutmeg is much stronger than pre-ground. A whole nut keeps for years in a jar.
Use a microplane, and a few strokes is enough for a whole pot of soup.
In savory dishes, it’s classic in pumpkin soup and creamy pasta sauces.
15. Cranberries

Cranberries, blueberries and Concord grapes are the three major commercial fruits native to North America.
Indigenous peoples harvested cranberries for thousands of years, and commercial growing started around 1812 with Henry Hall.
Tart cranberry against sweet pumpkin is a native-to-native match. Put them on the same plate and let them argue.
Fresh cranberries show up in fall, right when pumpkins do, and they freeze well for months.
Toss them onto a tray of roasting pumpkin for the last 10 minutes, until they just burst.
Dried cranberries work in pumpkin bread or salads, though most are sweetened with added sugar.
16. Piloncillo

Calabaza en tacha is Mexican candied pumpkin, simmered in syrup made from piloncillo (unrefined cane sugar) with cinnamon sticks and cloves.
Some cooks add orange zest.
It’s traditionally made for Día de Muertos and placed on ofrendas.
The name comes from the big pots, called tachas or tachos, it was cooked in.
It’s served in a bowl with its syrup and a little milk poured over the top.
Skip the milk or use a plant one if you’re keeping it vegan.
Piloncillo is sold in hard cones. Grate it or chop it, or let it melt slowly into the syrup.
17. Miso

In Yamanashi, Japan, the pumpkin is supposed to fall apart.
Hōtō is a stew of thick, flat wheat noodles in miso broth, and kabocha squash is its signature vegetable.
Fans say the pumpkin should simmer until it melts into the soup.
Local legend credits the warlord Takeda Shingen, and shops display his Fūrinkazan banner.
Miso brings umami.
The Umami Information Center lists its naturally occurring glutamate at 200 to 700 mg per 100 g, and that savory depth is the counterweight to pumpkin’s sweetness.
Watch the broth. Traditional hōtō uses dashi made with kombu plus dried anchovies (niboshi), and it often includes meat.
For a vegetarian bowl, use kombu or shiitake dashi.
18. Coconut Milk

Thai cooks skip the pie dish and steam custard inside the pumpkin itself.
Sangkhaya fak thong is coconut custard steamed in a whole pumpkin or kabocha.
“Sangkhaya” means custard and “fak thong” means pumpkin.
The filling is coconut milk, eggs and palm sugar, sometimes with pandan, so it isn’t vegan.
Coconut milk also pairs with pumpkin in curry, with one warning.
Traditional Thai red curry paste contains shrimp paste, and many commercial brands, Mae Ploy among them, include it.
Pick a paste labeled without shrimp paste and leave out the fish sauce most recipes add.
Swap cream for coconut milk in pumpkin soup. It’s just as rich and stays vegan.
19. Pumpkin Seeds

Pumpkin’s best partner might be its own seeds.
USDA data puts roasted pumpkin seed kernels at about 156 mg of magnesium per ounce.
Ground with chiles into pipián, the seeds make a sauce you can serve over roasted pumpkin.
Styrian pumpkin seed oil comes from hull-less seeds roasted and pressed into a dark green oil, with EU PGI protection since 1996.
In Styria, it even tops vanilla ice cream (which contains dairy).
To roast your own, rinse the seeds, dry them well and roast at 300°F until golden.
Whole seeds with shells are edible too. They’re just chewier and have more fiber than the green kernels.
20. Olive Oil

Pumpkin is loaded with beta-carotene and has almost no fat.
USDA figures for boiled pumpkin put it at 2,096 µg of beta-carotene and just 0.07 g of fat per 100 g.
That matters because carotenoids need fat to get absorbed.
In a small Iowa State study published in 2004, seven healthy adults ate salads of spinach, romaine, carrots and cherry tomatoes.
With fat-free dressing, they absorbed next to no carotenoids. Full-fat dressing beat reduced-fat dressing by 2.0-fold for beta-carotene.
That study used salad vegetables, not pumpkin.
The principle still applies, though: a drizzle of olive oil helps your body use pumpkin’s beta-carotene.
Cinnamon Has a Publicist
You don’t see sage getting a seasonal latte campaign. Cinnamon just had a better publicist.
Eat better, meat-free.
Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.
Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.