25 Naturally Red and White Foods for a Christmas Spread

Sarah Rose Levy
Sarah Rose Levy · 11 min read

A good cranberry bounces. A soft one doesn’t, and growers still sort the crop that way.

You don’t need a drop of food coloring for a red-and-white Christmas spread. The colors already come with the food.

Here are 25 naturally red and white foods to put on your table, each with something worth repeating once everyone sits down.

1. Cranberries

1. Cranberries

Cranberries float because each berry has tiny air pockets inside. That’s the whole trick behind those flooded bogs you see in the ads.

The vines actually grow on dry beds. At harvest, growers flood the beds, knock the berries loose and let them rise. In Massachusetts, more than 90% of the crop gets harvested that way.

Then there’s the bounce. The story goes that in 1880, a New Jersey farmer named John “Peg Leg” Webb, who had a wooden leg, couldn’t haul his berries down from the loft. So he poured them down the stairs.

The firm ones bounced all the way to the bottom. The soft ones stayed stuck on the steps. That’s how the industry tells the origin of the bounce-board separator, which is still used to sort berries today.

So if a cranberry bounces, it’s a good one. You’re allowed to test this at the table.

2. Popcorn

2. Popcorn

The earliest known popcorn garland on a Christmas tree goes back to 1842. A German-born teacher named Charles Minnigerode strung it on a tree he put up in Williamsburg, Virginia.

Store-bought ornaments weren’t easy to come by yet, and corn was cheap. American trees in the 1800s carried all kinds of edibles, including threaded strings of dried cranberries.

Which means the red-and-white garland is older than most ornaments in your attic.

3. Apples

3. Apples

Long before tinsel, the tree was red and white. Medieval mystery plays on December 24, the feast day of Adam and Eve, used a “paradise tree” hung with apples for the forbidden fruit and round white wafers for the Eucharist.

The modern Christmas tree has been related to that paradise tree. As it moved into homes, the apples were eventually swapped for shiny red baubles. The first glass ones came out of Lauscha, Germany, in 1847.

So a bowl of red apples on the table is basically the original ornament, back where it started.

4. Pomegranates

4. Pomegranates

A popular Jewish tradition says every pomegranate holds 613 seeds, one for each commandment in the Torah. Then a Columbia graduate student named Alexander Haubold actually counted.

He went through 206 pomegranates from around the world, and individual fruits held anywhere from 165 to 1,370 seeds. The average? Exactly 613.

Haubold himself said more counting would most likely move that number. And as Rabbi Dr. Ari Zivotofsky points out, the sages used the fruit as a metaphor for abundance, not a literal tally.

So no single pomegranate is guaranteed 613. One guy’s average landed on it anyway, which is somehow better.

5. Strawberries

5. Strawberries

Botanically, a strawberry isn’t a berry. It’s an “aggregate accessory fruit,” and the red part you eat is the swollen receptacle of the flower.

Those little “seeds” on the outside are each a tiny fruit of their own, called an achene, with a seed inside. So every strawberry is wearing its actual fruit on the outside.

Slice one down the middle and you get a white core inside red flesh. That’s two colors from one cut.

6. Raspberries

6. Raspberries

A raspberry is hollow because you leave its core behind on the plant when you pick it. A blackberry keeps its core, which is the easiest way to tell the two apart.

Each raspberry is a cluster of tiny drupelets. Set them hole-side up on a platter and they practically ask for a dot of something white.

7. Lingonberries

7. Lingonberries

Lingonberries pretty much preserve themselves. They carry so much natural benzoic acid that they keep well without any added preservatives.

In Sweden, people traditionally stored them in water as vattlingon, “water lingonberries.”

They show up at Christmas in another way too. The evergreen sprigs, berries still attached, have long been used as winter decoration, especially during Advent and Christmas. Most lingonberries are still picked wild.

The jam goes with pancakes, porridge and potato dishes, so it earns a spot on more than one plate.

8. Cherries

8. Cherries

A conventionally dyed maraschino cherry gets bleached before it gets red. These cherries soak in a brine that usually contains sulfur dioxide and calcium chloride to strip the fruit’s color, and then they’re dyed. As of 2010, American maraschino cherries typically used FD&C Red 40.

That method came from Ernest H. Wiegand, a horticulture professor at Oregon State University, around 1920. The original was the dark, sour Marasca cherry from Croatia’s Dalmatian coast, steeped in liqueur.

Real cherries are already red. Fresh ones are hard to find in a Northern Hemisphere December, so choose jarred or frozen dark or sour cherries with no added coloring. They’re also the star of item 24.

9. Blood oranges

9. Blood oranges

Cold helps a blood orange develop its red color. The color comes from anthocyanins, pigments that are uncommon in citrus, and they develop when the fruit grows through low nighttime temperatures.

That means no two are guaranteed the same shade. The three main types are Tarocco and the very dark Moro from Italy, plus Sanguinello from Spain. Sicily’s arancia rossa di Sicilia even has protected geographical status.

The timing works for you. In the U.S., Texas fruit runs December to March, and California’s runs November to May.

10. Red Anjou pears

10. Red Anjou pears

The whole Red Anjou variety started with one branch. In the early 1950s, a Green Anjou tree near Medford, Oregon, produced a single branch of red pears, a natural mutation growers call a bud sport.

It happened again in Parkdale, Oregon, in the late 1970s. Lightning striking twice, but with pears.

Red Anjous hit markets from late September or early October and stay through summer, so they’re right in season for Christmas. The catch is they barely change color as they ripen.

Press gently near the stem with your thumb. If it gives a little, it’s ready.

11. Lychees

11. Lychees

A lychee is a white fruit in a red shell. Peel back the pinkish-red rind and there’s a layer of translucent white flesh.

They’ve been a luxury for a long time. Tang emperor Xuanzong’s consort, Yang Guifei, loved fresh lychees so much that he had them delivered to the capital at great expense.

The Northern Hemisphere harvest runs May to June or July, so canned lychees are your year-round option. But in France, fresh lychees are a Christmas fruit, shipped and flown in from Madagascar for the holidays.

12. Dragon fruit

12. Dragon fruit

Dragon fruit grows on a climbing cactus whose flowers open overnight and usually wilt by the next evening. Bats or moths do the pollinating in that one-night window.

The common type has pink skin and white flesh speckled with black seeds. Cut one open and you’ve got your color scheme in a single slice. Another species has red flesh, if you want to go all red.

The common one is native to southern Mexico and the Pacific coast of Central America.

13. Radishes

13. Radishes

In Oaxaca, Mexico, December 23 is the Night of the Radishes, and you’re not supposed to eat the radishes.

Every year, carvers fill the main plaza with radish sculptures, including nativity scenes and Oaxacan traditions. The show radishes get fertilized so heavily they’re considered unfit to eat, and they can grow up to 50 cm long and 3 kg.

The radishes on your platter are the edible kind. Red skin, white inside, no carving required.

14. Chioggia beets

14. Chioggia beets

Chioggia beets have pink-and-white rings like a candy cane, right up until you cook them. The rings fade in the oven, so slice them raw if you want the stripes.

This Italian heirloom comes from the town of Chioggia, across the lagoon from Venice. It’s been on record since at least 1840, when Vilmorin first mentioned it.

The flavor is mild and sweet. Thin raw slices on a board do all the decorating for you.

15. Radicchio (Treviso tardivo)

15. Radicchio (Treviso tardivo)

Treviso tardivo gets its white ribs from two weeks in the dark. After harvest, the heads sit in tanks of running spring water with no light, and the new growth comes in without chlorophyll.

The result is deep red leaves with bright white ribs. The forcing technique is called imbianchimento, Italian for “whitening,” and it’s credited to a Belgian agronomist, Francesco Van den Borre, in 1860.

In Italy it’s called the “king of radicchio,” and it’s protected to the area around Treviso, Venice and Padua. It’s a winter vegetable, so Christmas is its moment.

Can’t find tardivo? The round Chioggia radicchio is the common U.S. type, and it’s red with white ribs too.

16. Red bell peppers

16. Red bell peppers

Most green bell peppers were picked before they ripened. Depending on the cultivar, they could turn red, yellow or orange, while some stay green.

USDA data gives raw red sweet peppers about 60% more vitamin C and nearly nine times the vitamin A (RAE) of raw green sweet peppers, gram for gram.

17. Tomatoes

17. Tomatoes

The U.S. Supreme Court officially ruled the tomato a vegetable. In Nix v. Hedden, decided May 10, 1893, the justices unanimously held that tomatoes count as vegetables under the Tariff Act of 1883.

The importer, John Nix, wanted his tomatoes classed as fruit, since the act put a duty on imported vegetables but not on fruit. Justice Gray admitted that botanically a tomato is the “fruit of a vine.” But people eat them with dinner, not as dessert, so for tariff purposes they’re vegetables.

Cherry tomatoes next to a white cheese made without animal rennet make a red-and-white board either way (cheese means dairy, so a white vegan cheese works too).

18. Red cabbage

18. Red cabbage

Rødkål, Danish braised red cabbage, became a Christmas dish in the 1800s during the period of national romanticism. Served next to boiled potatoes, it was supposed to make the table reflect the red and white of the Danish flag.

It’s on the table for Christmas Eve dinner on December 24.

There’s chemistry behind keeping it red, too. Red cabbage pigment is a natural pH indicator. It goes red in acid and bluish-green in alkaline conditions, so the acid in the braise keeps it on the red side.

One heads-up: some versions, including the one on Denmark’s official site, use honey. Plenty use sugar instead.

19. Cauliflower

19. Cauliflower

Cauliflower is white because it’s kept in the shade. The head, called the curd, is a dense cluster of undeveloped flower buds, and sunlight would trigger chlorophyll and turn it green or yellow.

The plant’s own leaves shade it. Growers often help by tying the outer leaves over the curd, a step called blanching. Some varieties do it themselves.

Sound familiar? It’s the same keep-it-in-the-dark idea as the Treviso radicchio in item 15.

The color rule cuts the other way too. Orange cauliflower traces back to a natural mutant found in a Canadian field, and purple cauliflower gets its color from anthocyanins, the same family of pigments as red cabbage.

20. White button mushrooms

20. White button mushrooms

Button mushrooms used to be brown. In the mid-1920s, a Pennsylvania grower, Louis Ferdinand Lambert by Popular Science’s account, spotted an odd white cluster in his growing beds, propagated it and called it “Snow White.”

Today’s white buttons trace back to that mutant.

Here’s the part that ruins menus. White button, cremini and portobello are all the same species, Agaricus bisporus, picked at different stages and colors. The portobello is basically a button mushroom that kept going.

21. Parsnips

21. Parsnips

A parsnip that sits through frost tastes sweeter. Cold soil turns some of the starch stored in the root into sugar.

In Europe, parsnips were a sugar source before cane and beet sugar were available. That’s a lot of responsibility for a root most people skip.

The skin and flesh are a light cream color, which makes them the quiet white on a roasted platter.

22. Coconut

22. Coconut

A coconut isn’t a nut. Botanically, it’s a drupe, the same fruit type as a peach or a plum.

The white flesh is solid endosperm, and coconut water is the liquid version. Coconut milk isn’t the water at all. It’s pressed from the grated white flesh.

At Christmas in Puerto Rico, that flesh turns into coquito (“little coconut”), the traditional holiday drink. It’s made with rum, coconut milk, cream of coconut, sweetened condensed milk and spices, and some recipes add eggs. It’s served all the way through Día de los Reyes in January.

So coquito usually means dairy and alcohol, sometimes eggs too.

23. Ricotta

23. Ricotta

“Ricotta” means “recooked.” Traditional Italian ricotta is made by heating the whey left over from making other cheeses, until the combination of low pH and high heat makes the protein clump into a fine curd.

In the U.S., it’s almost always made from cow’s milk whey. It’s dairy, obviously.

Ricotta itself is set with heat and acid rather than rennet. But the whey can come from cheeses that were made with animal rennet, so choose ricotta whose whey comes from cheese made without animal rennet. Check the label or confirm with the maker.

A spoonful of that vegetarian-suitable white ricotta next to anything red on this list does the work.

24. Risalamande

24. Risalamande

Somewhere in a bowl of Danish Christmas rice pudding, there’s one whole almond, and whoever finds it wins a prize.

Risalamande is the traditional Danish Christmas dessert. It’s rice pudding mixed with whipped cream, sugar, vanilla and chopped almonds, served cold with warm or cold cherry sauce, called kirsebærsovs. White pudding, red sauce.

On Christmas Eve, the hidden whole almond goes in. The winner gets the mandelgave, the “almond present,” which is often a marzipan pig.

The tradition is known from around 1900. Rice was an imported luxury back then, and the dish spread widely after World War II. It’s built on cream and usually milk-cooked rice, so it’s a dairy dessert.

25. Hibiscus (sorrel)

25. Hibiscus (sorrel)

In Jamaica, Christmas is deep red and it comes in a glass. Sorrel is made by steeping the calyces of the roselle plant, Hibiscus sabdariffa, often with ginger, cloves and allspice.

Those calyces are the fleshy cups around the seed pod, and they turn deep crimson as the fruit matures. They’re not leaves, and this isn’t the leafy green also called sorrel.

At Christmas it’s often spiked with rum. The plant’s season lines up with December, which helps explain the timing.

The same plant travels under a lot of names. It’s bissap in West Africa, agua de jamaica in Spanish-speaking countries and karkadeh in Egypt and Sudan.

The Cherry That Missed Christmas

The conventionally dyed maraschino cherry went through bleaching and a dye bath to dress for Christmas. You didn’t even put it on the guest list.

Eat better, meat-free.

Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.

Sarah Rose Levy
Written by Sarah Rose Levy

Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.

More Like This