25 Vegetarian Thanksgiving Dishes That Deserve a Spot on the Table

Sarah Rose Levy
Sarah Rose Levy · 10 min read

The best things on the Thanksgiving table are the sides, and most of America agrees.

A 2025 Campbell’s survey found 63% of Americans like the sides better than the entree. And 47% said they’d be happy with a plate of nothing but sides.

So the vegetarian at the table isn’t missing the meal. They’re eating the part everyone else came for.

There’s a catch, though. A lot of “obviously vegetarian” dishes quietly aren’t, because of what’s in the box. Here are 25 vegetarian Thanksgiving dishes that deserve a spot on the table, plus the labels worth reading before you dig in.

1. Stuffing

1. Stuffing

Stuffing is the #1 side in 42 states and top three in all 50.

It’s also the dish most likely to betray you.

Kraft’s Stove Top Savory Herbs lists meat and meat-based broth in its ingredients.

“Savory Herbs” sounds like the safe box. It isn’t.

Homemade doesn’t get a free pass either, since plenty of family versions use meat-based broth and sometimes meat.

Ask before you scoop.

Bake it in a separate dish, not the bird, and use vegetable stock. That’s the whole fix.

2. Mashed Potatoes

2. Mashed Potatoes

Second place nationally, and #1 in nine states.

The only question is whether somebody mashed them with meat-based broth, because some cooks do.

The other hidden one is gravy poured on before it reaches you, so ask for a plain scoop first.

Yukon Golds mash creamy and russets mash fluffy. Start either one in cold, salted water so it cooks evenly.

Make them a day ahead, then reheat them in a slow cooker with a splash of warm milk and butter.

3. Mushroom Gravy

3. Mushroom Gravy

Traditional gravy starts with meat drippings, so that boat isn’t yours.

A mushroom or vegetable gravy made with vegetarian stock and no meat drippings is, and honestly the potatoes can’t tell the difference.

Brown the mushrooms hard first. That deep color is where the savory, meaty flavor comes from.

A splash of soy sauce adds depth, and a spoon of miso does the same job.

Thicken it with a flour and butter roux, or whisk cornstarch into cold water first so it doesn’t clump.

4. Green Bean Casserole

4. Green Bean Casserole

This one’s a corporate invention.

Dorcas Reilly created it in 1955 in Campbell’s home economics department in Camden, New Jersey, and the original name was “Green Bean Bake.”

As of 2020, Campbell’s estimated it shows up at 20 million Thanksgiving dinners a year, and about 40% of the company’s cream of mushroom soup sales go into it.

Reilly donated the original recipe card to the National Inventors Hall of Fame in 2002, which is a better legacy than most casseroles get.

The classic version checks out, but check your can.

The risk is the “upgraded” one, because 1 in 5 Americans experiment with add-ins, some of which aren’t vegetarian.

5. Sweet Potato Casserole With Marshmallows

5. Sweet Potato Casserole With Marshmallows

Marshmallows on sweet potatoes started as an ad.

In 1917 the Angelus Marshmallow company hired Janet McKenzie Hill, founder of the Boston Cooking School Magazine, to write a recipe booklet.

It holds the earliest known printed recipe for mashed sweet potatoes baked under marshmallows.

It worked. Sweet potatoes are a top-three side in 24 states.

The problem is the topping.

Standard marshmallows contain gelatin, which comes from animals, so Dandies are the gelatin-free bag to look for.

Add the marshmallows in the last few minutes of baking so they toast instead of melting flat.

6. Mac and Cheese

6. Mac and Cheese

Nothing on the table is climbing faster.

It moved from fifth to fourth nationally, it’s #1 in Florida and New York, and it’s the top side for Gen Z at 41%.

70% of Gen Z think it belongs at every holiday meal. Gen Z is right.

James Hemings, Thomas Jefferson’s enslaved chef who trained in French cooking in Paris, is often credited with helping popularize it in America.

So it’s been a special-occasion dish for a very long time.

Check the cheese label. Some cheddars and Parmesans use animal rennet; look for microbial or vegetable rennet.

7. Cornbread

7. Cornbread

The classic blue box of Jiffy Corn Muffin Mix lists lard as an ingredient. Yes, the cornbread.

Jiffy also makes a separate Vegetarian Corn Muffin Mix that swaps the lard for vegetable shortening.

Jiffy sells a box labeled Vegetarian, which tells you everything about the other one.

Homemade cornbread usually uses butter or oil, but some Southern recipes call for bacon grease in the skillet.

Cornbread for stuffing works best a day old, so bake it ahead and let it dry out.

8. Corn Casserole

8. Corn Casserole

Cheesy, golden, and usually the first dish scraped clean.

It’s also usually built on that blue Jiffy box, so it inherits the lard from number 7.

The classic version is the muffin mix plus a can of creamed corn, whole corn, sour cream, butter and eggs.

Swap in the Vegetarian Jiffy box and the rest of the recipe stays exactly the same.

It bakes in about 45 minutes at 350°F, until the center is set, and the leftovers reheat well.

9. Cranberry Sauce

9. Cranberry Sauce

The label on the can is upside down on purpose.

The can is filled and labeled so the air bubble sits at the rounded end, which lets the log slide out whole.

Marcus Urann first produced cranberry sauce commercially in 1912 in Hanson, Massachusetts, and Ocean Spray took the canned version national in 1941.

It now sells tens of millions of cans a year.

An Ocean Spray survey found canned beats homemade in every region.

In the South it’s 68%. The ridges are the tradition.

10. Brussels Sprouts

10. Brussels Sprouts

Older varieties really were bitter.

In the 1990s Dutch plant breeders tied the bitterness to two compounds and bred them down, and a sweeter variety, Maximus, came out in 1994.

So newer sweeter varieties taste less bitter than those older ones.

Just ask whether they were roasted in meat drippings, because that’s the default “upgrade.”

Roast them cut side down at 425°F so the flat faces brown and turn sweet.

Balsamic glaze, maple syrup or toasted pecans make a vegetarian version where nobody misses the bacon.

11. Glazed Carrots

11. Glazed Carrots

Nobody fights over the carrots, and nobody skips them either.

They’re the designated driver of the table: sweet, reliable, never the problem.

The glaze is usually just butter with brown sugar or honey, a pinch of salt and sometimes orange juice.

Cut them the same size so they cook evenly, and simmer them until a knife slides in easily.

Then boil off the liquid until the glaze turns glossy and clings to every piece.

They can be cooked a day ahead and reheated gently on the stove.

12. Potato Gratin

12. Potato Gratin

Cream, potatoes, cheese. No notes.

One thing if it’s showered in Parmesan.

Real Parmigiano Reggiano is made with animal rennet under its protected-name rules, so the genuine stuff isn’t technically vegetarian.

Plenty of vegetarians eat it anyway, and that’s their call.

Look for a Parmesan-style cheese made with microbial or vegetable rennet. Traditional Gruyère has the same rennet issue.

Slice the potatoes thin and even, about an eighth of an inch, so every single layer cooks through at once.

13. Braised Greens

13. Braised Greens

Collards or kale cooked down until they give up, maybe with beans.

Ask what they were cooked with before you load your plate.

Southern greens are traditionally cooked with ham hocks, bacon or smoked turkey, so that’s the question to ask.

For a vegetarian pot, smoked paprika and a few drops of liquid smoke bring back that smoky flavor.

Simmer them in vegetable stock until tender, then finish with a splash of cider vinegar or hot sauce.

14. Wild Rice Pilaf

14. Wild Rice Pilaf

Wild rice isn’t rice.

It’s the seed of an aquatic grass, and the Ojibwe name, manoomin, is commonly translated as “good grain.”

Good grain is underselling it.

Most “wild rice” in stores is cultivated in paddies, while hand-harvested lake rice is pricier and cooks faster.

It takes about 45 minutes to an hour to simmer, until the grains split and curl open.

Toss it with mushrooms, dried cranberries, pecans and herbs, and cook it in vegetable stock instead of chicken.

15. A Fall Salad That’s Actually Good

15. A Fall Salad That's Actually Good

Every vegetarian knows the sad version.

The only thing you can eat is a green salad, and then there’s meat tossed in there too.

The good version has kale, shaved sprouts, apples and pecans, and people go back for it.

Massage the kale with a little dressing for a minute or two so it softens and loses some bitterness.

Keep the dressing on the side until serving, because dressed greens go limp fast on a buffet table.

Toast the pecans first. A few minutes in a dry skillet makes them taste much nuttier.

16. Butternut Squash Soup

16. Butternut Squash Soup

It looks like the safest bowl in the house.

But the stock may not be vegetarian, so ask whoever made it.

Plenty of recipes use chicken stock by default, which is the whole reason to ask.

Making it yourself? Roast the squash first for a deeper, sweeter flavor than boiling gives you.

It freezes well, so make it a week ahead and reheat it on Thursday.

Blend in a little coconut milk or cream at the end, and keep the cream out for vegan guests.

17. Dinner Rolls

17. Dinner Rolls

Often fine. Check the ingredient list on the tube or the bag anyway, then go back for more.

Most rolls are vegetarian, but some recipes use lard, and many brush the tops with butter.

Vegans have more to check: milk, butter, eggs and honey all show up in roll recipes.

Mono- and diglycerides can come from animal fat too, though the label won’t say which.

Bake homemade rolls ahead and freeze them. Warm them in a low oven right before dinner.

18. The Store-Bought Roast

18. The Store-Bought Roast

“But what’s your main?” already has an answer.

Seth Tibbott founded Turtle Island Foods in 1980, and the Tofurky roast launched in 1995.

It sold a few hundred roasts in 1995 and millions since.

It’s a wheat and tofu roast with wild rice and bread crumb stuffing, and it’s still made in Hood River, Oregon.

Field Roast’s Celebration Roast is another name you’ll hear.

Plenty of vegetarians skip the whole category.

If you don’t like meat, you’re probably not looking to replicate the meat-eating experience.

19. Stuffed Pumpkin

19. Stuffed Pumpkin

This isn’t a new trick.

The Christian Science Monitor was telling people to stuff a pumpkin for a vegetarian feast back in 1983.

Use a sugar or pie pumpkin, not a carving one. Carving pumpkins are stringy and watery inside.

Fill it with a cooked mix of wild rice, bread, mushrooms, cheese or nuts, then bake it whole.

Bake it with the lid on for about an hour, until a knife slides easily into the flesh.

Bring it to the table whole and cut it into wedges, filling and all.

20. Mushroom Wellington

20. Mushroom Wellington

This is the showpiece, the main that makes the rest of the table lean over and ask for a slice.

Store-bought pastry can contain lard, so read the box.

Cook the mushroom filling until it’s dry. Leftover moisture makes the bottom of the pastry soggy.

Plenty of frozen puff pastry is made with vegetable oil, not butter, so it can even work for vegans.

Assemble it the day before, chill it, and bake it straight from the fridge on Thursday.

21. Whole Roasted Cauliflower

21. Whole Roasted Cauliflower

It arrives whole and gets carved at the table, which is most of the appeal.

Some people fill it with stuffing. Respect.

Boil or steam the whole head for a few minutes first, so the inside turns tender before the outside browns.

Then rub it with oil and spices and roast it hot, around 425°F, until it’s deep golden.

A sauce is what turns it into a main. Tahini, romesco or a garlicky yogurt sauce all work.

22. Vegetable Lasagna

22. Vegetable Lasagna

The unglamorous one that always gets finished. Vegetable lasagna can take the main-course spot if a roast isn’t your thing.

Salt and drain watery vegetables like zucchini first, or the lasagna turns into soup when you cut it.

Let it rest 20 to 30 minutes after baking so the layers set and slice cleanly.

Assemble it a day ahead and refrigerate it. Add a little baking time if it goes in cold.

Use a vegetarian Parmesan-style cheese, since real Parmigiano Reggiano is made with animal rennet.

23. Pumpkin Pie

23. Pumpkin Pie

The #1 Thanksgiving dessert is hiding something.

Libby’s uses a pumpkin variety bred from Dickinson.

And Libby’s cannery in Morton, Illinois supplies roughly 80% of America’s canned pumpkin.

The real catch is the crust. Pillsbury’s refrigerated pie crust lists lard and hydrogenated lard in its ingredients.

Lard-free store crusts exist (Wewalka is marketed as one), so check the label.

The filling itself is usually pumpkin, eggs, sugar, spices and evaporated milk, so it’s vegetarian.

Bake it a day ahead. It needs hours to cool and set, and it slices better cold.

24. Apple Pie

24. Apple Pie

The #2 dessert, and the same crust rule applies. Read the box for lard, then relax.

Homemade crusts can go either way. Some old family recipes use lard, and many use all butter.

An all-butter crust is vegetarian, and a vegetable shortening crust can be vegan.

Mix a few apple varieties, like a tart Granny Smith with a sweeter Honeycrisp, for a better filling.

Bake it early in the day. It needs a few hours to cool so the filling can set.

25. Pecan Pie

25. Pecan Pie

The glossy version everyone knows came from corn syrup marketing.

Karo dates its pecan pie to the 1930s, and the recipe is still called “Karo Pie.”

That makes three “traditions” from three marketing departments: Campbell’s in 1955, Angelus in 1917, Karo in the 1930s.

Grandma had help.

The filling is eggs, sugar, corn syrup, butter and pecans, so it’s vegetarian once the crust checks out.

The Bottom Line

47% in the 2025 Campbell’s survey said they’d be happy with a plate of only sides.

So the most dangerous thing on a vegetarian’s Thanksgiving table isn’t the meat. You can see the meat coming. It’s a box of corn muffin mix.

Eat better, meat-free.

Get the best vegetarian finds, rankings, and hidden menu hacks delivered weekly.

Sarah Rose Levy
Written by Sarah Rose Levy

Covering vegetarian food, restaurants, and grocery finds across the U.S.

More Like This